By Tim Senn
In Jeremiah 23:28-29, the prophet writes:
“The prophet who has a dream may relate his dream, but let him who has My word speak My word in truth. What does straw have in common with grain?” declares the Lord. “Is not My word like fire?” declares the Lord, “and like a hammer which shatters a rock?”
Jeremiah was taking issue with those prophets in his day who were claiming to speak on behalf of God, but whose words were the “deception of their own heart” (v. 26). Jeremiah contended with them because they were feeding God’s people “straw” or “chaff” rather than the wholesome grain of God’s Word! As a result, God’s people were malnourished and weakened by spiritual famine.
Since the time of the Reformation, Bible believing churches have held to the principle of “Sola Scriptura,” a phrase which means, “by Scripture alone.” This doctrine maintains a belief in the unique authority and sufficiency of the Bible as the source for all we need to know God and to obey Him in our lives.
And yet in the evangelical world today there is a movement that challenges the sufficiency of Scripture by separating the ministry of the Holy Spirit from His Word in Holy Scripture. This teaching proposes that the Holy Spirit is giving new or fresh words to God’s people – not words that are on par with the authority of Scripture, but nevertheless words from God that allow us to experience His presence with us and which guide us in our decision making. The assumption behind this belief is that since God can guide us as He guided His people in the past through various forms of prophecy and revelation, that He continues to do so today. A scholarly explanation of this view has been given by Dr. Wayne Grudem in his book,
The Gift of Prophecy. A more popular and experiential version has been written about in Sarah Young’s bestselling book,
Jesus Calling. For two excellent critiques of Young’s book, click on the links at the bottom of this article.
In response to this teaching, the words of the hymn, “
How Firm a Foundation,” come to my mind: “What more can He say than to you He has said?” With those words, the hymn writer was affirming both the unique authority and sufficiency of Holy Scripture, the great doctrine of the Reformation called “Sola Scriptura.” It is a simple and yet profound question – “What more can He say?” Of course, God is able to say more than what He has revealed in the Bible – in that sense, He can say more. But that is not really what is being asked! The question is, “Does God
need to say more to us than what He has already revealed in the Scripture?” And “should we expect Him to say more?”
The answer of “Sola Scriptura” is “NO!!” At stake in this discussion is not simply who will win a theological argument – rather, it is the difference between whether we will dine up straw or feast upon wheat when it comes to our spiritual nourishment. Is the Bible alone sufficient for our source of spiritual bread, or should we be looking elsewhere for supplements to this heavenly food?
Over 400 years ago, Puritan pastor John Owen warned the church about separating the ministry of the Holy Spirit from the Bible:
“He that would utterly separate the Spirit from the Word had as good (as well) burn his Bible” (Ferguson, writing in “The Holy Spirit” by John Owen, p. 26).
I want to continue sound the same warning as I will show you that there is an unmistakable and unbreakable bond between the Holy Spirit and the Holy Bible. There exists a close correlation and harmony between the Holy Spirit and God’s written Word contained in the Scripture. In fact, God’s Word, now contained in the Bible, is inseparable from the Holy Spirit, Who both inspired the Scriptures and illumines believers so that we can properly understand it. I plan to show you that because God’s Word in Scripture is complete, that we should expect no “new words” or “new revelation” from God the Holy Spirit to the church today.
For a full explanation of this statement, please take time to listen to
the message I preached on September 16th, 2012. But let me refer to just one verse that supports this teaching.
The close link between the ministry of the Holy Spirit and the Holy Scripture is clearly set forth by the Apostle Paul in
Ephesians 6:17, who, when speaking about the various weapons in the spiritual armor of the believer says, “
and the sword of the Spirit, which is the word of God.” Notice from this verse that the Holy Spirit and His sword are both separate or distinct, and yet inseparable.
In other words, we must not collapse or confuse the two – the Holy Spirit is distinct from the Bible. He is a Person -- the Bible is His written Word. And yet, the sword or weapon or instrument that the Holy Spirit wields is the Word of God, which as we will see, is a clear reference to God’s written Word in Scripture. It is the media that He uses to minister to God’s people, and apart from His Sword, we should not expect any “immediate” words from Him! In all of His various ministries - conviction of sin, regeneration, the giving of faith and repentance, assurance, etc. - the weapon wielded by the Holy Spirit is the Bible.
Thus, we must not separate the work of the Spirit from the Word of God which He inspired. We must therefore be careful to avoid two errors: (1) We must not separate the Bible from the Holy Spirit – as if we could read and understand it apart from His help; and (2) We must not separate the Holy Spirit from the Bible, as if He would speak to us apart from or in addition to His Word.
I appreciate what Phillip Jensen says in his book, “Guidance and the Voice of God,”
This is the tragedy of the modern “hearing God’s voice” movement. It is so busy listening intently for what God might say in my head this morning, that it fails to hear what God is shouting at us this morning and every morning from the Scriptures (Jensen, p. 98).
The Bible says of itself that it is living and active – a fire and a hammer. Man does not and cannot live on bread alone, but derives his spiritual life from the teachings of the Bible. God the Holy Spirit works intimately each day to open our spiritual eyes and ears to understand what He has already written in Scripture – what could be more intimate than that? The Bible contains the living and enduring words of God – words that bring salvation and sanctification. Therefore, if you are desirous of hearing the voice of the living God, you will find it when the Holy Spirit applies the truths of the Scripture to our lives, and when He awakens within us a response of obedience to what God has already spoken once for all in the Bible!
“What more can He say than to you he hath said?"
Why seek the nourishment from straw, when the Bible offers you wholesome grain? What do the two really have in common?
ADDITIONAL RESOURCES:
Review from The Cripplegate
Review from Tim Challies
Tim Senn's message from 9/16/12